No offence meant, Pope tells 'defective' religions

Attempting to defuse a public relations disaster, the Pope said yesterday that a Vatican document which appeared to brand other religions defective was not intended to be insulting. But his conciliatory message was overshadowed by a controversial cardinal's call to close Italy's mosques and crack down on Muslim immigrants.

The Pope said that last month's text establishing the primacy of the Catholic church was not "arrogance that deprecates other religions but an expression of joyous gratitude".

The declaration, which appalled Protestants because it implied that they had "defects", had been misunderstood, he said.

"It's my hope that this declaration that I hold dear, after many mistaken interpretations, can finally serve its function as clarification and at the same time as an overture."

The Archbishop of Canterbury had led a chorus of criticism that the document had set back ecumenicism. Jews and Muslims, who were said to be in a gravely deficient situation, were also offended. A day to mark Christian-Jewish dialogue was cancelled.

Speaking to pilgrims in St Peter's Square, the Pope quashed suggestions that conservatives had rammed the text through the Vatican against his wishes. It was "approved by me", he said.

However, his conciliatory words were undermined by Cardinal Giacomo Biffi, a traditionalist and possible papal successor, who called for Italy's mosques to be closed.

Muslims should not be entitled to worship in Italy as long as Saudi Arabia and other countries prevented Christians from practising, he said.

Italy's swelling Muslim population was quietly waiting to become a majority and would then attempt to usurp the country's traditional Catholic identity, the archbishop of Bologna claimed. They were "outside our humanity", he added.


Your IP address will be logged

No offence meant, Pope tells 'defective' religions

This article appeared in the Guardian on Monday October 02 2000 . It was last updated at 11.35 on August 02 2002.

Most viewed on guardian.co.uk

  1. Loading …

Guardian Jobs

UK

Browse all jobs

USA

  • Physician - Family Practice - Family Medicine

    are part of a team and heritage. they join us for... pride in advancing education, appreciating the fine arts, and making visitors feel welcome. our public and... . mo.

  • PT / Physical Therapist

    with its deep western heritage to create a place... museums and a variety of districts highlighting arts and entertainment, the possibilities for adventure... . ok.

  • General Surgery Physician

    beaches, and a strong maritime heritage. experience the vibrant culture with its live theatre, music camp, center for the arts, museums and galleries, and a... . mi.

Browse all jobs